|
Whether you use a railpass or
point-to-point tickets, trains are easily the best way to travel
around Europe, no contest. Here's why:
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
 |
|
Speed & practicality...
European trains link almost every city & town at up to 198 mph, often faster than flying
as it's city
centre to city centre, no trek to the airport,
no 2-hour check-in, no airport security
strip-search. A '1 hour
flight' actually means 4-5 hours. Paris-Amsterdam
now takes 3h20 by train, Paris-Geneva 3h20... |
|
Comfort & a chance to relax...
...unlike air travel, train
travel is low-stress & low-hassle, and unlike bus travel
it's high comfort. After all, aren't you supposed
to be on holiday? On trains, you get space to move around,
lots of legroom (remember that?) and often a café, bar
or even restaurant.
Overnight sleeper trains cover huge distances while you
sleep, such as
Amsterdam to Prague or Paris to Barcelona, in effect faster than flying and it saves hotel bill, too.
The train journeys become a welcome chance to chill out between
cities... |
|
Scenery & the experience...
...and there's often superb scenery, too. Unlike flights or long distance buses
your train journeys become an integral part of your European experience,
something to enjoy for their own sake, giving you a real
ground-level
feel for the countries you're visiting...
Above: Scenery from a Milan-Paris TGV, with
my feet up & a glass of wine to hand... |
Trains versus buses, planes &
automobiles...
Planes:
In Europe, a 1-hour
flight means 4 or 5 hours of taking a bus/train/taxi to a remote airport
a long way out of town, a
lengthy check-in with humiliating security checks, and a flight
that may be delayed. In Europe,
flights average 63%-69% on time, whereas high-speed trains
often achieve
90%-95%. Then there's more airport arrival hassle followed by
another long bus/train/taxi ride into town. You miss out on the relaxing scenic overland journey which should be part of every European holiday.
To get cheap air tickets you must
arrange all your flights in advance on a no-refunds,
limited-changes basis, compared to the freedom &
flexibility of a go-as-you-please railpass.
And the extra cost of airport transfers, baggage fees,
check-in fees & credit cards fees must be factored into
the cost of the flight. Finally, short-haul
flights cause disproportionate
environmental damage, whereas trains are the
environmentally-responsible choice.
Car hire: In Europe, cars and city centres don't mix.
Hiring a car can be a great way to
explore a rural area off the main routes, such as
Tuscany or the Dordogne, but to see great cities such as Paris, Rome,
Barcelona or Florence, definitely don't hire a car.
Driving long distances in foreign countries can be tiring, long hours on motorways can be depressing,
traffic in urban areas can be a nightmare, and parking in
European city centres is either expensive or
non-existent. Some car hire companies won't let
their cars
cross borders even within the EU, others charge
prohibitive drop-off charges for doing so.
Long-distance bus: Long distance buses like
Eurolines or tourist buses like Busabout use
ugly motorways which spoil the scenery they pass
through. At 60 mph, a journey that's only 3
hours by train could be 8 hours by
bus. You're
stuck in a bus seat for hours & hours, no
restaurant or bar to go to, and at night
you sleep in your seat, a horrible
experience. Buses generally only serve the largest cities, often just once
a day, making them very inflexible.
You're not allowed to bring your own food & drink and there's certainly no alcohol permitted
on board!
Buses are really an option aimed at very, very
low-budget travellers... Avoid them if you can.
Train: Trains run on a vast rail network
covering almost every town & city in Europe, with a
range of departures every day. Trains run at
up to 198 mph (300 km/h), and are now faster than flying for many
key journeys such as London
to Paris (2h15), Paris
to Amsterdam (3h20), Paris to Geneva (3h20), Barcelona
to Madrid (2h40) or Florence to Venice (2h40). Overnight sleeper trains have beds
to sleep in and are an experience in themselves. They cover
huge distance while you sleep, such as Paris-Barcelona,
Paris-Florence, Amsterdam-Prague or Prague-Krakow, city centre to city
centre, saving a hotel bill and saving time over the 4-5
daytime hours that flying would use up. Trains
run city centre to city centre, low-hassle, zero stress.
There's loads of legroom, you can get up and wander to
the bar or restaurant car if you like. Feel free
to bring your own picnic and your own bottle of
wine or beer if you want, no problem, it's allowed on
trains! So
whether you use a rail pass or buy normal tickets, the train is
definitely the way to see a lot of Europe in a relatively short
time, in comfort. There's simply no contest. But more
than that, train travel is part of the European way of life, the way
we Europeans travel, and an experience in itself. You might
even meet some of us Europeans!
Here is a quick (OK, fairly
quick) guide to European railpasses, assuming you know
virtually nothing about them to start with, and talking you
through pretty much all the key points about buying
& using a railpass. If you need more detail, the other
sections on this page will help.
What is a railpass?
-
Let's start with the
basics. A railpass is a special ticket which gives you
unlimited train travel on the national rail network of
one or more
countries, so you can travel around freely and explore.
-
'Unlimited' means just
that. With a railpass, you can take one train or fifty trains,
travel 10 miles or 800 miles a day, for the same fixed price.
-
A 'railpass' is different
from an ordinary point-to-point ticket. A point to point
ticket allows you to make just one specific journey from A to B.
Point to point tickets vary in price, long journeys cost more than
short journeys, booking in advance is often cheaper than buying
on the day, and fares in (say) Switzerland are more expensive
than fares in (say) Bulgaria.
-
So if all you want to
do is make one simple journey from A to B, a point to point ticket
is probably what you need. But if you want to travel round extensively
making multiple journeys and travelling flexibly, a railpass may
be what you need.
Is a railpass cheaper
than buying point-to-point tickets?
-
There's no easy answer
to this,
because it depends on what journeys you want to do. The pass price is fixed
whatever journeys you make with it, but point-to-point prices vary enormously
in price, some are cheap,
others expensive, depending on the distance, the
country, where you buy them, and whether you book a cheap
ticket in advance or a more expensive ticket on the day. But
here are the 'rules of thumb':
-
If you're only
making a few short journeys, you're almost certainly better
off buying ordinary point-to-point tickets at the station on the
day. For example, Florence to Pisa costs 5.70 euros, so why buy a railpass costing around €40-€50 per day
just to make a €5.70 journey?
Even Brussels to Amsterdam on the hourly
InterCity trains costs only €37, full-price, even on the day
of travel. For help finding out what point-to-point fares
would cost,
see here.
-
Italy deserves a
special mention, as it's such a popular destination. Rome to
Florence costs 44 euros full fare by 'Eurostar Italia' high-speed
train, Florence to Venice 42 euros, even bought on the day.
Rome-Venice costs 73 euros. With passes typically working
out at 40-50 euros per day plus a 10 euro passholder surcharge
required for every journey on a Eurostar Italia train, railpasses for
Italy only make sense if you plan to do the equivalent of
Rome-Venice every time you step onto a train. They do not
make financial sense if you're only going Rome-Florence day 1,
Florence-Venice day 2, Venice-Verona day 3, etc. You can check
Italian train fares online at
www.trenitalia.com. There are similar issues with
railpasses versus normal tickets in Spain and in eastern Europe,
see here.
-
For a pre-planned
fixed-itinerary trip around Europe, the cheapest option is
usually to buy cheap advance-purchase point-to-point tickets
online direct from the European train operators. There are some
amazing bargain train tickets available, the rail equivalent of
'budget airline' fares, available up to 3 months in advance at
the
relevant European train operator websites. For example,
it's not difficult to find a 25 euro Paris-Geneva ticket at the
French railways website
www.voyages-sncf.com and print out your own ticket or collect
it at the station in Paris. The 25 euro fare includes the
'Lyria TGV' reservation, with no credit card fee, no booking
fee & no postage. Is this €25 deal cheaper than a
€40-€50 per day railpass, plus travel agency fee & postage,
plus the €8 passholder surcharge for the Lyria TGV (I'll
explain about surcharges in a minute)? You bet! So don't buy
a pass for pre-planned trips before checking what cheap point-to-point
fares were available,
see the advice in this section.
-
For long-distance
spontaneous & flexible trips: That cheap 25 euro
Paris-Geneva ticket might be the cheapest option if you can
pre-plan, but it means 'no
refunds, no changes to travel plans'. You must book a
month or two in advance, and maybe the €25 price will be
available when you want it or maybe it won't. The normal
flexible 'on the day' price for Paris-Geneva is
around €75. Does a €40-€50 railpass make sense now,
even with €8 Lyria TGV surcharge? Yes, the railpass now
saves you money! The pass gives you the flexibility to change your mind
and your plans as you go.
-
To sum up, don't assume you need a railpass. Short distance and
many medium distance trips are best made with an ordinary
point-to-point ticket bought at the station on the day. For
a long-distance pre-planned fixed-itinerary trip around Europe,
the cheapest option is usually to buy a series of
cheap advance-purchase point-to-point tickets from the various
European train operator websites booking a month or two in advance, if the cheap deals are available
when you want them (and many will be) and if you don't mind a 'no refunds, no changes to travel plans' ticket.
However, if flexibility is important to you, a railpass is a fixed price for
go-as-you-please freedom. Although even with a pass, a few seat reservations
may be required and there's the odd surcharge to pay, more about
that in a minute.
-
The only way to know for sure whether a railpass
or point-to-point would be cheaper is to work out the point to
point prices for most of the trips you're planning using the
various European train operator websites (not overseas ticketing
agency websites which often charge more or ignore the cheap deals,
I mean buying direct from the French railways website, the German
railways website, and so on, at European prices with all the
European special deals). If you're on a
tight budget, taking the time and effort to do this can save you a
lot of money, so
see this section.
-
Don't be afraid to
mix & match a railpass with one or more point to point tickets.
For example, for 11 days of train travel in Europe, it's cheaper
to buy a 10-day Eurail Global pass plus one point-to-point ticket
for the shortest/cheapest of all your train rides, than to buy the
next pass size up, which is the 15-day Eurail Global pass.
If the start of your trip is known and fixed, the rest flexible,
you could buy a cheap ticket for the first one or two journeys,
then start using a railpass.
What trains does a
railpass cover?
-
Railpasses cover all
the trains run by the main national train operator in each country
covered by the pass, be they local trains, suburban trains,
regional trains, inter-city trains & international trains.
Occasionally (notably in Switzerland) they also cover a few
private train operators as well.
-
Railpasses do not
cover metro or Underground ('subway') trains (or for that matter,
buses or trams) within cities. Nor do they cover some small
private operators, such as the Circumvesuviana Railway in Italy
(Naples-Pompeii-Sorrento), FEVE or Euskotren narrow gauge local
trains in northern Spain, or some private operators in Switzerland
such as the Jungfraubahn up the Jungfrau and the Matterhorn Gotthard Bahn in
Switzerland which operates the line to Zermatt & half of the
Glacier Express route.
-
Railpasses also
don't cover Eurostar, the high-speed train through the Channel
Tunnel between London & Paris or London & Brussels. In fact
that's not totally true, because there's are 'discounted'
passholder fares, but as these passholder fares are actually more
expensive than the cheapest book-ahead fare (yes, really!) there
may as well not do. Only if you suddenly need to use
Eurostar at short notice will the passholder fare be less than the
regular fare.
-
You'll find a list of
what operators are covered by railpasses in the
country by country guide below.
How do passes work?
Seat reservations & surcharges...
-
Generally speaking, you
can simply hop on any train you like, find any empty seat to sit
in, and show your railpass when asked by the conductor.
-
However (and
it's a big 'however'), people who think buying a railpass means
there's nothing further to pay sometimes get a shock. Many
premium daytime trains require railpass holders to pay a small
surcharge and/or make a seat reservation. Here are the
rough 'rules of thumb':
-
Local,
suburban & regional trains almost never require
seat reservations or surcharges in any country.
Just hop on!
-
Belgium, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Switzerland, Germany,
Austria, Denmark: With a handful of
exceptions, internal & international
trains within and between these countries don't require
a seat reservation or surcharge, even on
premier high-speed inter-city trains like Germany's
superb ICE. You just hop on. Railpasses retain their 'convenience factor'
in these countries, as you can hop on & off trains
spontaneously. However, even though it's optional,
making a seat reservation for a long journey can be a
smart move as it guarantees you a seat, well worth the
3-5 euro seat reservation fee. Key exceptions:
Thalys trains between Brussels & Amsterdam and Brussels
& Cologne have compulsory reservation & a special fare
for railpass holders. A few scenic tourist trains
in Switzerland require a seat reservation & small
supplement, such as the famous Glacier Express & Bernina
Express. International journeys from these
countries into France, Italy or Spain do require
reservations and supplements. Although they don't
participate in the Eurail pass scheme, trains in
Britain & Ireland are also 'reservation
optional', never compulsory, and there are no passholder
surcharges.
-
France,
Italy, Spain, Portugal, Sweden:
This is the problem area. Virtually all
domestic & international trains to, from, between &
within these countries require compulsory seat
reservation & payment of a passholder surcharge of some
sort, varying from 3 to 20 euros per trip. I
suggest using 10 euros
per train ride as a rule of thumb for budgeting purposes. Railpasses have
lost their 'convenience factor' in these
countries as you can't just hop on, you need to make a
reservation, even though you make a reservation ten
minutes before the train leaves (in Italy, simply use
the excellent
self-service machines at every main station with an
English-language touch screen). Although you'll seldom find trains
fully-booked except at key holiday periods, be aware of
the possible quota
problem with reservation-compulsory trains in these
countries, especially France.
-
In
Eastern Europe it varies. Some
premier trains require a seat reservation (3-5 euros
fee), these will be shown in the timetable with an 'R'
symbol.
-
Sleeper
trains: You'll need to pay a supplement and
make a reservation for
sleepers or
couchette on overnight trains, in all countries.
Fr budgeting purposes, reckon on 20 euros supplement for
a couchette in a 6-bunk compartment or 50 euros per
person for a bed in a 2-bed sleeper, in eastern Europe
it's cheaper, reckon on 15 euros for a couchette or 26
euros for a bed in a 2-bed sleeper. Remember that
with Eurail and
InterRail flexi rail passes, an overnight train
leaving after 19:00 counts as running on the following
day (as long as the overall validity period has started), so it only uses up one day of your rail pass.
-
You'll
find a detailed list of which trains require compulsory seat
reservations, and what surcharges cost, in the
country-by-country guide below.
-
You'll
find a more detailed guide to using a Eurail pass,
including validating a Eurail when you first start to use it,
in the How do
Eurail passes work section.
How to
make reservations with a railpass...
-
At
stations: You
can easily make seat or berth reservations and pay any
surcharges at the station as you travel
around, there are almost always places available on any
given train even in summer, though of course some trains
do get full at
peak times. Notably, the
Paris-Italy 'Artesia' sleeper trains do leave
fully-booked in summer, as do many high-speed trains in
Spain, so think about pre-booking those. Also be aware of the
annoying
passholder quota
problem, especially in France. European
reservation systems are linked, so you can usually (but
not always) make reservations for a journey starting at
stations other than the one you're at, even in different
countries.
-
In
advance, using train operator websites:
Unfortunately, train operator websites usually only sell
complete tickets and don't allow railpass holders to
make 'reservation only' bookings. The useful exceptions
are the German railways website
www.bahn.de (for trains to, from & within Germany,
also sleeper trains from Amsterdam to Prague/Copenhagen/Zurich/Munich,
and Paris to Berlin/Munich)
and the Italian railways website
www.trenitalia.com (though this has trouble
accepting many non-Italian credit cards,
see
here). In both
cases, use the journey planner as if you were going to
buy a ticket. On bahn.de you're then given the
option to make your booking 'reservation only'. On
Trenitalia.com, select a train, then change the drop
down fare box to 'other fares' then 'Global pass'.
As you pay the ticket office price with no fees or
postage, this is the best way to make a reservation if
you can.
-
In
advance, online or by phone from the overseas agency
which sells your railpass: You can
usually make reservations by phone
or online from the agency which sells you the pass. You
can make seat or berth reservations to go with a railpass
on many western European trains at any of these agency
websites, although bear in mind that agencies will
charge a bit more that you'd pay at the station (or
online direct from the train operator) and add a booking
fee or postage fee on top.
What types of railpass
are there?
-
European residents qualify for the
InterRail pass range. They do not qualify for
the Eurail pass range. So if you're a European citizen or an overseas
citizen who has been resident in a European country for more than 6
months, go straight to the InterRail pass
page where all will be explained. Citizens of the
Russian Federation & Turkey plus a few other north African
countries also qualify for InterRail passes.
-
Overseas visitors (Americans,
Australians and so on)
qualify for the Eurail pass range. If you are not
resident in Europe you cannot buy an InterRail pass. Citizens of the Russian Federation & Turkey do
not qualify for Eurail passes, they qualify for InterRail
passes.
-
InterRail & Eurail passes cover exactly
the same trains. So a European and (say) an American can
travel together, the European using an InterRail and the
American using a Eurail, no problem.
-
There are a handful of other railpasses that
anyone qualifies for, for example a Swiss Pass,
explained here.
Understanding the Eurail pass range...
-
Eurail is the pass range for overseas
visitors who don't live in Europe.
-
Eurail (often mispronounced 'Eurorail')
isn't a company or a train operator. It's simply the
brand-name for a range of international rail passes for overseas
visitors to Europe, offered jointly by the various national train
operators. There are no special 'Eurail' trains, Eurail
passes simply give unlimited travel on all the normal scheduled train
services run by the various national train operators.
-
The national railways participating in the Eurail scheme are
Austria, Belgium, Croatia, Czech Republic (which joined in
January 2009), Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece,
Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal,
Romania, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden & Switzerland.
-
You can see the countries covered with this
map of rail network in the Eurail countries
-
Eurail Global, Eurail Selectpass &
Eurail Single-country: The first choice is between a Eurail Global
pass covering almost the whole of Europe, a 'Eurail
Selectpass' covering your choice of any 3, 4 or 5 neighbouring
European countries, or a 'Eurail single country pass' covering
just the one European country of your choice.
-
'Continuous' & 'Flexi':
Eurail Global passes come in both 'continuous' & 'Flexi' versions.
The original 'continuous' version gives unlimited train
travel around most of Europe for a continuous period of either 15
days, 2 days, 1 month, 2 months or 3 months starting on any date
you specify. The 'Flexi' version only gives either 10
or 15 days free train travel within an overall 2-month period,
with the ability to 'spend' those unlimited travel days on
whichever days you choose within the 2 month period. The
Eurail Selectpasses all work on the 'Flexi' principle with a
choice of 5, 6, 8, 10 or 15 days unlimited train travel within a
2-month period, as do the Eurail single-country passes
which offer a choice or 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 or 8 days unlimited
train travel within an overall 1-month period.
-
How do 'Flexi' passes work?
Let's say you buy a 10-days-in-2-months Eurail Global 'Flexi'
pass. The 2 month overall period starts on any date you
specify. There are 10 empty 'boxes' printed on your pass.
Each time you want to 'spend' one of your 10 unlimited travel
days, you simply write the date in ball-point pen in one of the
boxes, and you then have 24 hours unlimited train travel from
midnight to midnight in the area covered by the pass. In
fact, it can be more than 24 hours, because of the 'overnight
train rule'. An overnight train leaving after 19:00 counts
as the following day, so you could in theory start travelling just
after 19:00 on a sleeper train, then travel all around through the
next day until midnight.
-
Adult, Youth & 'Saver': Each
type of Eurail pass comes in adult, youth & saver versions.
Youth means anyone under 26. 'Saver' simply gives a discount
for 2-5 people all buying Eurail passes and travelling together.
-
You can mix & match passes:
Don't be afraid to buy a combination of passes. If you were
spending 5 days in France and 5 days in Italy, two 5-day
single-country passes would be the cheapest pass option, a 10-day
Eurail Selectpass covering both France and Italy costs a bit more,
though would give you more flexibility. A 10-day Eurail
Global pass would cost more than either of these options, but to
no purpose if you're really only going to visit France and Italy.
Though of course, if you changed your mind and suddenly wanted to
see Amsterdam, you could do that with the Global Pass...
-
Detailed advice on how Eurail passes work, including how to
validate your Eurail pass at a station when you arrive in Europe.
Other railpasses worth mentioning...
How do I buy a
Eurail pass, browse pass types or check current Eurail prices?
You'll find the quick answer to this question in the
Quick guide to
Railpasses section above, but here's the more detailed
version...
People seem to think there's a definite answer, such as 'a
rail pass is always cheaper than normal tickets if you're
going to Switzerland, but normal tickets are always cheaper
than a pass if you're going to Italy or Spain or eastern
Europe'. It's true that some rail passes (like the
excellent Swiss pass) are better value than others (like
railpasses for Italy or eastern Europe where fares
are so cheap anyway), as you have to clock up more mileage
in Italy to justify the pass, whereas it doesn't take
much in Switzerland to make a Swiss Pass worthwhile.
But it depends on how much travelling you plan to do,
and on which sort of point-to-point ticket you compare it with.
A $70-a-day railpass (even with a $10 reservation fee on
top) is cheaper than a $150 fully-flexible buy-it-on-the-day
point-to-point ticket, but much more expensive than a $45 cheap
point-to-point
ticket bought online in advance on a
no-refunds-no-changes-to-travel-plans basis. So
there's no simple answer without working it out for
yourself.
OK, so how do I work it out?
Here is a step-by-step guide to checking whether a pass will
actually save you money over normal tickets. If you
find this too difficult, can't be bothered or can't afford to spend half an hour working
it
out, skip this bit and go straight to the
Which railpass should I buy section. But a little legwork
can save you a lot of money. Here's how:
-
Decide where you want to go:
First, decide which countries and
which cities you want to visit. This is the fun
bit! Decide what interests you, and use a good
European guide book like the
Lonely Planet Guides or Rough
Guides. If possible,
sketch out a rough itinerary. It doesn't have to
be detailed, though you can use the invaluable online timetable at
http://bahn.hafas.de to plan train times if you
like.
-
Decide
which railpass best fits this itinerary: Look for
the rail pass that most closely fits your trip, see
what rail pass should I
buy?
-
Work out the 'pass-price-per-day':
Divide the rail pass price by the number of days train
travelling you expect to do, to get a 'pass price per
day'. This is your yardstick.
-
Allow for railpass supplements:
Remember that in addition to the cost of the pass,
passholders have to pay a surcharge to travel on many long-distance
premium trains. You'll also need to pay a sleeper
or couchette supplement on overnight trains (though these save a hotel
bill). A rough 'rule of thumb' for budgeting
purposes is to add 10 euros per journey for any
daytime long-distance journey to, from, between or
within France, Italy or Spain, but there's seldom any
supplement to pay on trains within or between
Switzerland, Germany, Austria and the Netherlands, and
in eastern Europe there either is no supplement or it is
small, say 3-6 euros. For overnight trainsl, again
as a rough rule of thumb, add 20 euros for a basic
couchette or 50 euros for a bed in a 2-bed sleeper (per
person) for any overnight journey. For a more
accurate and route-specific idea of which trains do and
don't have supplements, and how much they cost, see the
do I need to make reservations
or pay supplements? section.
-
Find out what the point-to-point fares would be:
See
how
can I find out what the point-to-point fare would be?.
The point-to-point fares produced by the journey
planners on railway websites include any
supplement or reservation charge, so no supplement
worries here. You'll need to
decide if you want flexibility and the ability to vary
your itinerary and be spontaneous (in which case, you
should compare the rail pass price with the most
expensive fully-flexible fare shown in the journey
planner search results) or if you are
prepared to commit to specific trains on specific dates,
to take advantage of cheapest advance-purchase fares.
-
And compare the two:
Compare the pass price per day with the typical
point-to-point fare for the sort of journeys you expect
to make. If you've planned an itinerary, compare the
cost of the pass with the cost of normal tickets for
those journeys.
-
Don't forget that a rail pass is more flexible,
usually allows you to hop on and off trains
spontaneously, saves you time queuing at ticket offices,
and may cover additional trips that you didn't expect to
make (for example, if you plan to spend a few days in
Paris, it will cover a daytrip to Versailles).
Even if a rail pass is a bit more expensive, it can still
be better to buy one.
The examples below show that it pays to do your research.
Don't assume that a rail pass is always the most economical
option. In fact, your working assumption should be the exact
opposite: Assume that normal
point to point tickets are the cheapest option unless
you can prove that a rail pass will save you money.
-
There's one other problem with railpasses that can
occasionally raise its head, especially at busy times
and especially (it seems) on TGV services in France and
on trains between Paris & Italy, Paris & Switzerland,
Paris & Belgium/The Netherlands. I'm not sure how
often it happens, as it's only cropped up in people's emails to
me once or twice - but perhaps many railpassholders are
simply told the train is full, and go away thinking it
really is full when if you're paying cash there's lots
of seats left.
-
Here's the problem: In the old days, if you had a
railpass you were treated as having a normal 2nd class
ticket, on an equal footing with other passengers.
So if there was one seat left on the train and you were
first in the queue to make a seat reservation on that train
with your railpass, then you got it and the person
behind you didn't. But many trains in western
Europe are now yield-managed, meaning that the number of
seats sold at each price is controlled by a quota held
in the
reservation system, and there's a separate quota for
railpassholders. At busy times this quota can be
very small or even zero. So now, if there's one
seat left on the train, a railpass holder is told "Sorry,
the train is full" (in other words, there are no
passholder places available), and the seat is sold to the passenger behind you
willing to pay cash. They already have your money
after all, as you've already paid for the railpass!
Personally, I think this is sharp practice, though as I
say it may not be a problem except on certain trains at
very busy times. But you should be aware of how
things work. If you need to be on a specific train
on a specific date, a normal point-to-point ticket
booked on that train guarantees you a place, whereas
simply holding a railpass and expecting to make a
reservation at the station on the day may not, even if
there are seats available! Of
course, you could buy any mission-critical reservations
along with the pass from the same agency in the same
phone call, so you only buy the pass if the reservations
are OK.
Common railpass mistakes: Italy...
-
Many people buy a railpass to tour Italy, but fares in
Italy are very cheap. A
railpass typically costs 40-45 euros
per day (this is the pass price converted into euros and divided by the number of days
of free train travel). Perhaps this sounds good
value. But all fast trains in Italy now require a
10 euro passholder reservation surcharge even with a pass, so there's
no 'convenience factor' in having a pass, you still have
to make a seat reservation, and with the surcharge added
the pass price per day becomes 50-55 euros per day.
-
They then travel from Rome to Florence on day 1, a
journey which only costs 44 euros for a full fare
point-to-point ticket including high-speed train
reservation, bought at the ticket office even on the day
of travel. Next day they do a day trip to Siena, a
16 euros return ticket. Then they go from Florence
to Venice, a 42 euro ticket. Venice to Verona is
less than 25 euros. So why buy a pass? Venice to Rome is only
73 euros, so now a pass does save money, but you need to
do a journey of this length every day of your pass
validity to make it pay. You can check
normal ticket prices for Italy at
www.trenitalia.com. You want 'Base' fares for
flexibility, although if you pre-book in advance you can
get a 30% or even 60% discount,
if
you can persuade Trenitalia to accept your credit card.
-
Conclusion: A railpass seldom makes sense for Italy
unless you plan to commute between Milan and Sicily, as
passes are overpriced relative to normal Italian point-to-point fares.
Eastern Europe is also cheap, so be careful about
buying a pass for those countries, too.
Switzerland is just the opposite, where high
point-to-point fares and good-value railpasses make
railpasses a good bet.
Common railpass mistakes: Eastern Europe...
-
Many people buy a railpass to tour eastern Europe.
But as with Italy, normal fares in that part of Europe
are so cheap anyway it hardly makes sense to use a pass.
Bought at the ticket office when you're there, you can
often find cheap deals too, making point-to-point even
cheaper.
-
For example, an InterRail pass (for Europeans) costs
around £48 per day. The normal fully-flexible fare
from Prague to Krakow is only 1,068 koruna (£35) if you
buy it at the station in Prague, but usually they can do
you a cheaper fare of 855 koruna (£29). So why buy
a pass?
-
It's often difficult to buy tickets online (or even just
find out the real ticket-office fare) for journeys in
eastern Europe, but it's easy to buy tickets at the
station when you're there. Bear in mind that
tickets for eastern European journeys bought from UK, US
or Australian agencies are usually more expensive than
the price you'd pay at the ticket office when you're
there.
Common railpass mistakes: Budget train fares for
Spain...
-
A railpass typically costs the equivalent of 40-45 euros
per day (the pass price converted into euros and divided
by the number of days validity). But remember that
every long-distance train in Spain now requires a
reservation even with a pass, and passholders have to
pay a supplement of around 6 to 10 euros per train ride.
-
If you insist on flexibility, a pass will probably save
money on balance over full-fare buy-on-the-day tickets
for long-distance journeys. For example,
railpass-per-day + supplement = 45 + 10 = 55 euros.
A full-fare Madrid-Seville ticket costs around 75 euros.
The pass saves 20 euros on this trip.
-
But if you're prepared to book in advance and commit to
a fixed itinerary, you can buy cheap 'Web' fares online
at www.renfe.es, in
this case Madrid-Seville costs only 28 euros, saving 27
euros over using a railpass. These blow railpasses
out of the water price-wise. And less queuing at
the ticket office as you print out your own ticket and
breeze onto the train!
-
Conclusion: Cheap book-ahead online 'web'
fares are a better bet for travel around Spain, if
you're prepared to pre-book on a 'no refunds, no changes
to travel plans' basis. Remember to budget for the
supplements which apply to all fast trains in Spain
Common railpass mistakes: Budget train fares in
western Europe...
-
Passholders now have to make a reservation and pay a
special passholder fare (typically 5 to 15 euros) before
boarding most international trains in western Europe,
certainly those involving France, Spain and Italy, so
passes have lost their convenience factor. You can
no longer just hop on and show your pass, you need to
queue up at the ticket office to make a reservation.
-
The same trains have adopted airline-style
point-to-point fares, with cheap fares if you book in
advance on a 'no refunds, no changes to travel plans'
basis, and much more expensive fares if you buy a
fully-flexible ticket on the day of travel.
-
Let's take a typical example. Paris to Geneva,
Bern, Basel or Lausanne in Switzerland by high-speed TGV
starts at £25 one-way for a cheap point-to-point ticket
if you book in advance, rising to £90 for a fully
flexible buy-on-the-day ticket. This compares with
an InterRail pass (for Europeans) costing around £48 per
day plus an £8 passholder fare or a Eurail pass (for
non-Europeans) costing maybe 45 euros per day plus a 10
euros passholder fare.
-
So if you insist on flexibility, railpasses may save
money over normal full-fare tickets for long-distance
trips. In our example, the pass cost was £48 + £8
= £56, the fully-flexible fare was £90.
-
However, if you're prepared to commit to a fixed
itinerary, the cheap book-ahead train fares blow
railpasses out of the water price-wise. £25 using
a cheap point-to-point ticket versus £56 using a pass,
half the cost! Of course, maybe the £25 tickets
have sold out for your date of travel, so maybe you end
up paying £35 or £45 instead, whatever, but it's still
cheaper than buying the pass. And you can easily
buy the cheap point-to-point ticket online with no
booking fee, whereas the railpass and supplement cannot
be booked online direct from the train companies, you
will probably have to buy them from an agency, and the
agency will no doubt add a booking fee or postage charge
on top. So why bother with the pass, just go
online and snap up that cheap ticket!
-
A particular example to note are the Paris-Madrid,
Paris-Barcelona, Zurich-Barcelona &
Milan-Barcelona overnight 'trainhotels'.
For travel in a 4-berth sleeper, a special
point-to-point fare of around 75 euros (£67) is easy to
get on almost all trainhotels up to a few weeks before
departure, when the fare goes up to the fully-flexible
fare of 130 euros (not a very sophisticated fare
structure, I grant you!). When I go to Spain from
the UK, this £67 sleeper fare is what I always buy.
An InterRail pass costs around £48 per day (or, for
non-Europeans, a Eurail pass maybe 45 euros per day),
then you have to pay a 75 euros (£67) supplement for the
same 4-bed sleeper. That's right, the supplement
is £67/75 euros, exactly the same price as the book-ahead
fare that everyone in their right mind pays without a
pass. So why bother buying the pass? I
certainly don't bother with a railpass for any
international trips I make from the UK to Spain,
Switzerland or Italy.
-
Also worth quoting as an example are the City Night Line
sleeper trains on routes such as Amsterdam-Prague,
Amsterdam-Vienna, Paris-Berlin, Paris-Munich and so
on. Their budget fares start at 49 euros including
a couchette, whereas with a pass you have to pay a 20
euros couchette supplement plus the cost of the pass.
Again, if you're prepared to pre-book an can get the
cheapest rates, passes don't make sense.
-
Conclusion: 'Budget train fares' have
arrived, as train operators copy budget airlines and
offer very cheap point-to-point deals if you book in
advance. If you're prepared to pre-book your
itinerary a couple of months in advance on a
'no-refunds, no-changes-to-travel-plans' basis online
direct from a European train operator (as opposed to
buying from an overseas booking agency), these cheap
fares blow railpasses out of the water price-wise.
There's advice on how to book which train tickets on the
How to buy European
train tickets page.
|
|